Saturday, October 1, 2016

This is gonna go here due to the subject material.

This is gonna go here due to the subject material.

I'm not sure how much I've talked about this (come on google, search within a collection should be easy), but I have a family history of major problems as a result of complications from the fatness.

I've been trying -- and failing! -- to lose weight for years.

I'm scared of diabetes. Of strokes. Of heart disease. But, that's all far away and hasn't worked as sufficient motivator to lose weight.

I also think that if I continued to be fat and to gain weight each year when I could have done otherwise, that that'd be a morally blameworthy action.

Let me explain that a little, as I lose people there.
Guiding Principle: If I know the outcome of a situation, and do not act to prevent it, I bear (some measure of) responsibility for the outcome.

Belief 1: I and pretty much I alone am responsible for what I put in my mouth. I control my limbs, and control how much I exercise.

Belief 2: I know that being fat will (or, rather, is likely to, but it works the same) result in major medical problems in twenty years, for me. Note: This has little if anything to do with your weight, and has to do with my family medical history.

Lemma 1: I am responsible for the medical outcomes that happen if I am fat.

Belief 3: Medical resources are not infinite; if I go to the ER for a heart attack, then someone else has to wait for treatment or go without.

Lemma 2: If I suffer from preventable medical treatments, other people will be harmed.

Along with the guiding principle, we get something like:
Conclusion: My being fat is a contributory & morally blameworthy factor that causes harm to others.

So ... yeah. I want to lose weight. More than that, I think it is morally blameworthy for me not to. I think my being fat would cause harm to others, and that I can prevent that harm by not being anymore.

I've intentionally put this into the language of logic, more or less. I've tried to make it less emotional, because damn my feelings on this remain raw. It gets into all sorts of issues, but I think this is fairly clear.

I've tried to stress this throughout, and will do so again here: This is about me. Its not about you. I'm not calling you immoral. I'm not saying what you should or should not do.

9 comments:

  1. I've mentioned this before (maybe on one of your posts), but one of the big dividing lines between overweight and fit people (who want to be fit, some overweight people are fine where there are) is where they feel control of their weight is: external sources like genetics or luck vs internal sources like habits and diet.

    Your Belief 1 is probably the most important thing.

    ReplyDelete
  2. (do you mind if I share this to my Physical Training collection?)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I suggest trying to find immediate reasons to keep you on track. I agree with your thesis, and my personal attention to diet and exercise is also somewhat based on FMH. Taking responsibility is step 1 but then what can motivate you from day to day? Personally I enjoyed getting my metabolism where it was when I was a kid. "Nothing tastes as good as skinny feels?" I donno, but you'll need something sustaining if you really want to lower your risks. I think threatening to donate to Trump will only get you so far. 😉

    ReplyDelete
  4. Aaron Griffin The bet is $200 to the local catholic church for local activism. Never Trump.

    The local catholic church can do a lot of harm -- most of it confined to my rich, liberal community. I also see them on a regular basis, as I walk by the church to hit most resteraunts. It is very peronsonally motivating, without the possibility of ending the world like giving to Trump.

    When I won the first bet, I gave the money to an actual charity instead. As soon as I win this one (time pressure!), I'm planning -- but not committing, because post-bet William is free -- to give it to HRC.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have before eaten a pint of ice cream while trying to stop, and unable to do so.

    That really messed with the belief that I'm in charge of my limbs, and a more nuanced version might be that my habits dictate the actions of my limbs, and I can over time and with sufficient attention modify my habits. Incentives make modifying those behaviors easier.

    So for ex, when my nephew visited and got a pint of ice cream? I didn't have any. And that's me responding to incentives.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I'm ok with you sharing, Aaron Griffin .

    ReplyDelete
  7. Oh man, they're gonna spend that money on abstinence education :)

    ReplyDelete