On the distinction between fucks and spoons.
tl;dr - If you can do it but don’t want to then you’re short on fucks, not spoons.
This is my current thinking, and I'd be happy to amend it. I think there's an important conversation to be had.
Prelude: Most of the time, I don’t count my spoons. Most of the time, I can do the things I want to do, and then some. Most of the time. Sometimes it is not; a year and a half ago I suffered an injury that left me unable to readily leave the house. Or shower. Or do a variety of other normal activities. At that point, I was counting my spoons.
Which is to say: I’m not just talking from a place of privilege, but I am talking to privilege. Mostly.
There’s been some call of late for able bodied and well people to not use the spoon metaphor when describing our lives, as it becomes appropriation and ableist bullshit. This is important, but erases components of the initial metaphor. In the original metaphor, everyone has spoons. Some spoons come back faster than others, some people have a lot more spoons. Some people have unlimited spoons. But, everybody has spoons.
Still, there is an important distinction to be made. I know I’ve started talking about spoons, and using the metaphor to describe situations where I absolutely can do something,, and I simply view it as a burdensome hassle.
And, well, that’s not being out of spoons. That’s having no fucks left to give. From here, the two can feel the same -- because it is so easy to forget what it is to be low on spoons.
Examples, from my own life:
"I have no more fucks left to give!" -- said when I choose not to engage with a topic because it won't be productive, and will siphon off energy that I want to hoard.
"I don't have the spoons for that." -- used when I cannot bring myself to do a thing, whether due to pain or energy or cognitive limitations or other things. One example: When i had to buy a shower bench because I could not stand for long enough to bathe.
Question is: If you want to not be guilty of appropriation, which should you use?
1. If coffee, ibuprofen, or other OTC medications would solve the problem, then fucks. For example, before my morning coffee I give no fucks; I want the coffee and everything else fades from mind. But, I absolutely could solve other problems if necessary.
2. Did you stop reading this, because you don’t give two fucks on the difference between spoons and fucks? Then fucks.
3. If you are at a place where the two seem like the same thing? Use spoons. That is, if not wanting to do something and not being able to seem only minorly different, you probably have low spoons.
4. Was getting out of bed painful, and did you have just enough spoons to feed the cat? Did you then fall down, and wish it could end? You are low on spoons.
5. Were you unable to read this, because it took a spoon you didn’t have? Spoons.
That's where I'm at, anyway.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Pretty well put.
ReplyDeleteHee! I would like a metric fuckton of spoons, please.
ReplyDeleteMm. I think the line you're pointing toward becomes significantly more blurred when mental health concerns are thrown into the mix.
ReplyDeleteMiles Peiser I think that's true, and would like to hear more!
ReplyDeleteFor example, prereg nearly triggered a panic attack. I had to look at the spoons and wonder if it was worth it.
Mental health issues can definitely deplete spoons. While there are qualitative differences between why someone with for example depression can't get out of bed and why someone with CFS/ME can't, both of those people have a similar effect, well past the level of giving fucks and into spoon debt. Even mental health issues that can grant energy can remove spoons by redirecting all of someone's energy away from baseline necessary activities.
ReplyDeleteMy particular mental health issues often make it difficult for me to differentiate between fucks and spoons. Like, when my anxiety is really bad, I tend to think spoons are fucks, and it's not until later that I realize that no. Those were spoons.
ReplyDelete(haha I'm not making any sense)
Anna Kreider On the contrary! You're pointing to a really important thing.
ReplyDeleteThis is a thing I didn't point out well. Thinking about fucks versus spoons requires a measure of self-knowledge which, when our fucks are gone and we're into spoons, is really hard. REALLY HARD.
Gretchen S. Oh, this is also really important!
ReplyDeleteSome activities cost spoons and grant fucks, right?
And if you regain spoons really fast, then you do that and don't care because having additional fucks is awesome.
But if you regain spoons slowly or have a low number or start with or just have to keep track of them, then you have to spend a spoon to think about if you should do that and then you've already spent a spoon and maybe you want the fucks but you probably don't have the spoons to spare to get them.
Yes/No/Totally and absolutely wrong?
Haha, I'm low on spoons today, so math is a bit challenging, but that conversion rate sounds right. :)
ReplyDeleteAlso, giving a fuck can deplete spoons.
ReplyDeleteGretchen S. I'd be interesting in hearing how spending a fuck can use a spoon. I'll also understand if you don't have the spoons to explain. :-)
ReplyDeleteWhen I give a fuck about something, I often invest physical and/or emotional energy into supporting or doing that thing. This uses spoons. I am going to Ireland because I give a fuck about fulfilling my dreams and learning, but I'll be spoonless for weeks after.
ReplyDeleteWilliam Nichols If I care about something that's beyond my current capacity to really engage with, it can burn spoons even if I end up using them just being upset about the whatever, or doing a third of it and flopping over. So I've been learning how to disengage giving fucks unless I think I have spoons to back the fucks. Sometimes I care even if it wouldn't be productive to, and it eats spoons, and that's life, but sometimes I can sort of detach and spend my fucks somewhere else that I can back them.
ReplyDelete(Haha, I want to make a dirty joke now.)
We're rearranging the kitchen today, which I give a lot of fucks about, because we just didn't have enough shelving and I want it to be great, and it's MUCH harder to move a shelf once it has stuff on it, but it has a lot of lifting and bending (like for cleaning the floors under the old inadequate shelves), so I've been getting Sweetie to literally do all of the heavy lifting, while I rest, and then I come in and play tetris for a while, tell him the measurements for the next shelf going onto the poles, and then have another lie-down or noodle on the computer.
ReplyDeleteSometimes he catches me trying to lift something he knows will tire me out too fast and chases me away.
Brianna Sheldon That makes sense! Because you care about Ireland, you are willing to have fewer spoons than you want in the future in order to accomplish the goal. I see that!
ReplyDeleteI think it may be slightly different from the spoons/fucks distinction, but I'm not sure. Are there times when you don't give a fuck about going to Ireland?
Gretchen S. Oh, the jokes! I have tried to avoid them, but caught myself saying "Do you have a moment and a fuck that won't cost a spoon to engage on this issue?" ... which is a really weird thing to say!
ReplyDeleteThat story makes sense! You give several fucks about the state of the kitchen, but do not have the spoons to fully engage. Now I think I understand better what Brianna Sheldon was going for, too!
Learning!